Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!
🍛 There are dishes that feed your stomach, and then there’s Paneer Butter Masala—the North Indian classic that feeds your soul. That velvety tomato gravy hugging soft paneer cubes, the whisper of kasuri methi in every bite, the way it makes even the simplest roti feel like a feast. This isn’t just food; it’s edible nostalgia.
Why This Recipe Works When Others Fail
- The cashew trick – Soaked cashews give that restaurant-style creaminess without overwhelming richness
- Kashmiri chili powder – All the color with half the heat (perfect for kids!)
- Double butter treatment – Cook the base in butter, finish with butter
- Kasuri methi magic – That secret dhaba-style aroma in one sprinkle
🛒 The Ingredients (And Why They Matter)
For the Soul (Gravy)
- 4 tomatoes – Ripeness matters! Squeeze test: should dent slightly
- 15 cashews – Soak 30 mins (or cheat with hot water for 10)
- 1″ ginger + 8 garlic cloves – The dynamic flavor duo
For the Star (Paneer)
- 500g paneer – Homemade or store-bought? Pro tip: Soak store-bought in warm water first
- 1 tbsp each oil + butter – Because life’s too short to choose
The Spice Symphony
- 1.5 tbsp Kashmiri chili – For color not burn
- 1 tbsp coriander powder – The unsung hero
- Kasuri methi – Crush between palms to awaken
👩🍳 The Method (With All My Mistakes)
1. The Paste That Makes or Breaks You
What I did wrong: Once blended tomatoes raw → acidic disaster
Now: Quick roast tomatoes in 1 tsp oil first → deeper flavor
- Blend tomatoes + garlic + ginger + cashews + spices into velvet
- Texture test: Should coat spoon like ketchup
2. Paneer: To Fry or Not to Fry?
Myth: Must fry paneer
Truth: Soak in hot salted water 15 mins → just as soft!
For Crispy Lovers
- Heat oil + butter → medium flame
- Fry paneer 1 min/side → golden not brown
For Soft Purists
- 2 cups hot water + 1 tsp salt
- Soak paneer 15 mins → pat dry
3. Building the Gravy (Slow & Steady Wins)
- Step 1: Tempering – Whole spices in hot oil till they “dance”
- Step 2: Onions → golden not brown (15 mins patience pays!)
- Step 3: Paste → cook till oil separates (the make-or-break moment)
- Step 4: Simmer sauce + paneer + cream → 5 mins max
💡 Pro Tips From My 27 Failed Attempts
- Cream timing: Add at end → swirl don’t stir
- Color secret: 1/4 tsp beetroot powder if tomatoes are pale
- Leftover hack: Add boiled potatoes → “Paneer Aloo Butter Masala”
- Kid-friendly: Replace chili with 1/2 cup grated carrots
🍽️ Serving Suggestions That Wow
Presentation hack: Serve in copper handi → garnish with cream swirl + coriander sprig. Light a tea candle underneath for that dhaba drama!
🤔 FAQs (Real Questions From My DMs)
Q: Can I make this without cream?
A: Yes! Swap with:
• 2 tbsp cashew paste (soaked cashews + milk)
• 1/4 cup full-fat coconut milk
• 2 tbsp hung curd (add at end)
Q: My gravy tastes bitter—help!
A: 3 fixes:
1. Burned spices? Strain and add 1 tsp sugar
2. Overcooked garlic? Add 1 tbsp cream
3. Kasuri methi overdose? Squeeze lemon
💬 Did this recipe save your dinner? Tag @khanakhzana with your #PBMasterpiece!